parallel evolution

Tennessen JA & Akey JM 2011 Parallel adaptive divergence among geographically diverse human populations. PLoS Genet 7:e1002127.

  • most putative examples of adaptive divergence between human populations lack the full signature of a classic hard sweep
  • classic sweeps may have played a negligible role in the evolutionary changes that have occurred since the most recent common human ancestor
  • divergent loci may indicate more complex and subtle modes of selection
  • it is often difficult to demonstrate with statistical confidence that they are not merely the tail end of a stochastic neutral distribution
  • if selection acts independently on the same loci in different geographical locations, data from multiple populations can be leveraged to provide strong evidence for non-neutral evolution
  • demonstration of parallel evolution among populations provides strong support for the hypothesis that repeated selection of the same alleles in distinct environments is an important mechanism of local adaptation
  • the goal is to test whether the same SNPs show high divergence in phylogenetically independent contrasts
  • to this end, we calculate pairwise FST for all SNPs between all pairs of groups
  • for each pair of groups, we identify divergent SNPs that exceed the 95th percentile of FST values
  • our results are consistent with fluctuations in the allele frequencies of standing variation, as in soft sweeps
  • although alleles have rarely actually swept to fixation
  • the tempered changes at most loci suggest that they encode quantitative polygenic traits that have reached new optima
  • that fitness landscapes fluctuate too rapidly
  • that the sweeps are still ongoing
  • and/or that gene flow prevents fixation